GTA vs Red Dead Redemption

Which Rockstar epic is the masterpiece?

Tap a side to vote

Ad slot

The debate

GTA's satirical open-world crime sprees turned it into the best-selling entertainment product ever made, while Red Dead Redemption's slow-burn frontier storytelling set a new bar for narrative depth.

Tale of the tape

🚔 GTA

Copies sold: 410M+
GTA V revenue: $8B+

🤠 Red Dead Redemption

Metacritic score: 97
Copies sold: 73M+

Games standing

Full leaderboard →

GTA

#17 / 18

1420 ELO

Red Dead Redemption

#2 / 18

1580 ELO

Join the debate

0 comments

No comments yet. Start the argument. 🐐

Keep the debates going

Mario vs Sonic

Who's gaming's greatest mascot?

Cast your vote →

Call of Duty vs Battlefield

Which shooter franchise wins?

Cast your vote →

FIFA vs eFootball (PES)

Which football sim is the real deal?

Cast your vote →

Ad slot