What is the main difference between Elden Ring and Dark Souls III?

The main difference is the game design, with Elden Ring featuring an open-world approach and Dark Souls III having a linear design.

Which game is considered more challenging?

Dark Souls III is often considered more challenging due to its intense difficulty and refined mechanics.

How have the games been received by critics and players?

Both games have received high praise, with Elden Ring receiving a Metacritic score of 96 and Dark Souls III scoring 89.

🎮 Games

Elden Ring vs Dark Souls III

Better FromSoftware game?

Tap a side to vote

Skip to next

Who's winning: Elden Ring or Dark Souls III?

No votes yet — be the first to weigh in on Elden Ring vs Dark Souls III.

Elden Ring's open-world design and Dark Souls III's refined linear approach have sparked divergent opinions. Fans argue over which game best represents FromSoftware's vision. The debate centers on the trade-off between freedom and focus. Gamers must weigh their preferences.

Why each side wins

💍 Elden Ring

Elden Ring offers an expansive world to explore, with a complex web of interconnected locations. This design allows for a high degree of player freedom and discovery. The game's open-world format has attracted a wide audience, with many praising its immersive atmosphere.

🔥 Dark Souls III

Dark Souls III, on the other hand, delivers a tightly focused experience, with a clear and challenging path to follow. The game's refined mechanics and intense difficulty have made it a favorite among fans of the series. Its linear design ensures a consistent and polished experience.

Tale of the tape

💍 Elden Ring

Copies sold: 25M+
Metacritic: 96

🔥 Dark Souls III

Copies sold: 10M+
Metacritic: 89

The verdict

The choice between Elden Ring and Dark Souls III depends on individual preferences for game design. Those who value freedom and exploration may prefer Elden Ring, while others who enjoy a more focused and challenging experience may prefer Dark Souls III. Ultimately, the decision comes down to personal taste.

Games standing

Full leaderboard →

Elden Ring

#19 / 88

1500 ELO

Dark Souls III

#20 / 88

1500 ELO

Frequently asked

What is the main difference between Elden Ring and Dark Souls III?: The main difference is the game design, with Elden Ring featuring an open-world approach and Dark Souls III having a linear design.
Which game is considered more challenging?: Dark Souls III is often considered more challenging due to its intense difficulty and refined mechanics.
How have the games been received by critics and players?: Both games have received high praise, with Elden Ring receiving a Metacritic score of 96 and Dark Souls III scoring 89.