What is the significance of Advice Dog's debut year?

Advice Dog's 2006 debut marked the beginning of the advice-animal meme format, influencing many subsequent memes.

What makes Guilty Dog's expression so relatable?

Guilty Dog's 'you had one job' expression and sheepish demeanor make it a lovable representation of everyday failures and mistakes.

How do the two dogs differ in terms of meme style?

Advice Dog is known for its optimistic and upbeat vibe, while Guilty Dog conveys a more playful, self-deprecating humor.

😹 Meme Animals

Advice Dog vs Guilty Dog

Which classic advice-animal dog meme is the GOAT?

Tap a side to vote

Skip to next

Who's winning: Advice Dog or Guilty Dog?

No votes yet — be the first to weigh in on Advice Dog vs Guilty Dog.

Advice Dog's 2006 debut introduced the advice-animal format. This matchup pits the original against Guilty Dog, a relatable reaction pup. The debate centers on which dog's meme legacy endures. Fans argue over their favorite canine counsel.

Why each side wins

🐶 Advice Dog

Advice Dog pioneered the advice-animal genre, setting the stage for countless memes. Its smiling face and rainbow background evoke a sense of optimism. As the original, it retains a special place in meme history. Its influence can be seen in many subsequent memes.

🙈 Guilty Dog

Guilty Dog's 'you had one job' expression resonates with people who laugh at lovable failures. Its sheepish demeanor makes it a go-to face for lighthearted humor. Guilty Dog's versatility in conveying playful regret has made it a staple in internet culture. It often represents the humor in everyday mistakes.

Tale of the tape

🐶 Advice Dog

Went viral: 2006
Format: Advice animal OG

🙈 Guilty Dog

Format: Reaction pup
Mood: Sorry, not sorry

The verdict

Weighing the choice between Advice Dog and Guilty Dog depends on whether you value the original meme or its most relatable offspring. Some people prefer the classic, upbeat vibe of Advice Dog, while others enjoy Guilty Dog's humorous, self-deprecating humor. Ultimately, the decision comes down to personal taste in meme style.

Meme Animals standing

Full leaderboard →

Advice Dog

#37 / 62

1500 ELO

Guilty Dog

#38 / 62

1500 ELO

Frequently asked

What is the significance of Advice Dog's debut year?: Advice Dog's 2006 debut marked the beginning of the advice-animal meme format, influencing many subsequent memes.
What makes Guilty Dog's expression so relatable?: Guilty Dog's 'you had one job' expression and sheepish demeanor make it a lovable representation of everyday failures and mistakes.
How do the two dogs differ in terms of meme style?: Advice Dog is known for its optimistic and upbeat vibe, while Guilty Dog conveys a more playful, self-deprecating humor.